Hello dear
Welcome To 4 Keeps
4 Keeps, located in Pewaukee, Wisconsin, is a beloved local bar known for its vibrant atmosphere and community-oriented spirit. Formerly the Pickled Egg, this establishment excels at crafting memorable experiences with its friendly bartenders who treat patrons like family. The menu has expanded to include delightful offerings, such as their highly praised garlic bread. Customers rave about the exceptional Bloody Marys, making 4 Keeps a must-visit for those seeking quality drinks and great conversations. With a commitment to community involvement, 4 Keeps truly lives up to its name: it's a place you'll want to return to again and again.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
4 Keeps
Welcome to 4 Keeps, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Pewaukee, Wisconsin, at 206 Oakton Ave. This lively bar is more than just a drinking spot; it’s a community hub where friends gather and memories are made. The ambiance is inviting, reminiscent of the classic “Cheers” bar experience where everyone knows your name.
Stepping inside, you’re greeted by the warm smiles of the bartenders, who are known for their outstanding service and unique personality. Customers like Kathleen Krause rave about their friendly demeanor, noting how they take time to connect with patrons, ensuring a personalized experience every visit. The amazing bartenders at 4 Keeps are more than menu masters; they’re producers of joy, crafting drinks that beckon you to come back for more.
What sets 4 Keeps apart is not only their stellar beverages but also an expanding food menu that has delighted returning customers. The garlic bread, mentioned fondly by loyal visitors, is a must-try. With each bite, you’ll experience flavors that complement the vibrant bar atmosphere—a testament to the thoughtful expansion of their culinary offerings.
As noted by Crystal Knott, 4 Keeps stands out for its renowned Bloody Marys that have people longing for their signature mix. It’s a quintessential Wisconsin bar experience; clean, welcoming, and rich with character. Whether you’re sharing laughs over a drink or engaging in a friendly game of cribbage with fellow patrons, the sense of community is palpable here.
4 Keeps embodies the spirit of connection and nostalgia, where the owner and staff treat you like family, making it a place you’ll want to visit time and again. With its commitment to the community and friendly atmosphere, it’s no wonder guests are eager to return. So, if you’re in the area, grab a drink, chat with the vibrant staff, and experience first-hand why 4 Keeps is truly a place for keeps!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I love this place! It has been great even since it was PIckled Egg. I have no idea what this other reviewer is talking about the bartender I think she's talking about is amazing! She's unique and fun! Super friendly, always smiling and always willing to recommend or make a new fun drink/shot if you ask. The bartenders take time to get to know the customers and have a really great ability to remember names, which makes you feel like you are walking into "Cheers". I love the atmosphere! They have some more food now, which is awesome! I love their garlic bread! The staff has always been attentive to the customers when I go in. I have MANY friends who frequent this bar on a weekly basis for their Thursday night special. I'm so happy this place has remained open, kept the same awesome bartender, and expanded their food menu...surefire ways to keep the customers coming back for more! ”
“ Every time we head back to Wisconsin, 4Keeps is a must-stop on our list. They just don’t make Bloody Marys as good where we live now—seriously, we’ve tried, and it’s been a disaster. But at 4Keeps? They know how it’s done! The owner and bartenders treat you like family, and no matter how long we’ve been away, they always make us feel like we never left. It’s a true Wisconsin bar—clean, welcoming, and full of character. Whether you’re in the mood for a perfectly crafted drink or just a great time, this is the spot. They also give back to the community, and if you know me, you know this is super important. 4Keeps lives up to the name—you’ll keep coming back because this place is 4Keeps. ”
“ Stop in every so often. Great bartenders, always a smile ”
“ I have not tried the food as of yet. So I can't rate that part as yet. But the atmosphere and service are top notch excellent. 4Keeps is a very unknown bar that should be much MORE well known! ”
“ Great spot to have a cold beverage and great conversation with the bartends and other patrons! There is usually someone willing to paly a little cribbage or other bar games. A regular spot for sure! ”
“ My wife and I just moved to Pewaukee and today we came in for the first time. It was a busy bar and we were still greeted and served immediately by Becca who was so kind and very attentive to every patron that she was serving. She made our time there very enjoyable. We stayed through the shift change where we met the next bartender was Nikki who was also so wonderful and on top of taking care of everyone. The bartenders are fantastic. 4 Keeps is a great bar and we plan to make it our new home bar and can’t wait to go back! Thank you 4 Keeps! ”
“ We were so very impressed with Christie! We were looking for a fun, low-key place to have a couple drinks out of town and found it! Very attentive and personable and we WILL be back :-) ”
“ Great Bloody Marys! Open early. Had a great time here while my wife was participating in an event in Pewaukee. Friendly locals great staff. Fun little tavern. Conveniently located near the river and lake. Great place to start or stay for a day of fun. ”